Thursday, August 11, 2005

Least action and non-classical paths

Here's a funky piece of physics discovered in condensed matter research that deserves broader attention because it is so weird.

So, the Feynmann-Hibbs path integral approach to quantum mechanics says that the way to calculate the probability of a quantum system starting at configuration {a} and ending at configuration {b} is to add up the complex amplitudes for all possible paths between {a} and {b}. For each path, you can compute the classical action, S, by integrating the Lagrangian along the path, and the amplitude for such a path is given by exp^(i S / \hbar). This is particularly nice because paths that extremize S end up constructively interfering (having very similar phases). So, when one passes to the classical limit (\hbar -> 0), one finds that the dominant classical trajectory for the system is the one that extremizes the action. Unsurprisingly, the trajectory that dominates is something smooth that looks like a sensible classical path (e.g. for a particle propagating in free space, it's a straight line from point a to point b).

Here's the weirdness, though. There is at least one system (quantum tunneling of spin in molecular magnets) for which the action-extremizing paths are discontinuous. In our free particle discussion, these would be analogous to trajectories where the particle's path in space looks like _____----____--__ , complete with discontinuous changes in coordinates. Such trajectories are always in the calculations (in fact, in quantum field theory you need to include paths with space-like discontinuities (!) in order to get the calculations to come out correctly), but this is the only case I've ever seen where they can be the dominant trajectories.

No comments: